Bonim B’Yachad welcomes questions and comments.

Please submit your inquiry below and a member of our staff will be in touch with you as soon as possible.

Yigdal Yadin 47/52 

Modi'in, Israel, 7171607

Tel: +972 52-773-5224

United States

2501 Hal Circle

Baltimore, MD 21209

Tel: +1 (732) 572-6575

Fax: +1 (410) 510-1202

R. Yerachmiel Zelcer published his Ner Le-Me’ah, a collection of 100 answers to the Beis Yosef’s question...

  • They divided the oil into eight parts and used one-eighth each night

  • After they filled the menorah each night, the bottle of oil was miraculously refilled

  • On each morning, they found the menorah refilled with oil

  • Not all the oil burned the first day so a little would remain on the second, because a blessing/miracle can only impact an existent item  

  • One day of Chanukah celebrates the military victory  

  • The first day commemorates the rededication of the Temple by the Hasmoneans

  • The eight days correspond to the eight days of circumcision, which the Greeks outlawed

  • The receptacles used as a menorah were broken and could not contain a full day’s amount of oil but still miraculously burned for a full day

  • The first day commemorates the dedication of the Second Temple when it was built – R. Yaakov Emden

  • Finding the bottle of pure oil was in itself a miracle

  • The Geonic work She’eiltos has a different version of the Talmudic passage (as it often does) which reads that they did not even have enough oil for one day

  • There was only enough oil for the first night but the menorah must be lit all day also

  • They were forbidden to extinguish the fire on the morning of the first day in order to conserve oil yet the oil continued burning through the eighth evening

  • The eighth day is celebrated out of doubt, as all holidays are observed outside of Israel

  • They planned on using multiple wicks dipped in the oil but the original wicks miraculously lasted all day

  • They lit in the courtyard rather than the inner chamber. The greater wind created a need for more oil

  • The month of Kislev was short that year but is now long (29 vs. 30 days). We still observe the holiday from 25 Kislev through 2 Teives even though it is now eight days rather than the original seven

  • On the first day, after they found the bottle with only enough oil for one day, it miraculously became enough for eight days

  • There was enough oil for lighting the menorah but not for relighting the western light in the morning, as it was each day

  • They thinned the wicks so they would only use 1/8th of the oil. The miracle was that the flame was as strong as if they used full wicks

  • The bottle only had enough for one light for one day but it lasted for all seven lights for eight days

  • They lit the menorah before dark on the evening of 24 Kislev, so the miracle also applied to the end of the first day

  • We are not allowed to make a replica of Temple utensils. We therefore celebrate for eight days so the menorah will have eight branches, rather than seven like the Temple menorah

  • Eight days like Sukkos

  • The miracle was not in the quantity of oil but the quality, that it burned eight times slower than normal, which also occurred on the first day